Things had been unraveling for weeks. Honestly, I should have known from the beginning that it wasn’t going to work. He was too diffident. Too closed off. Too mysterious. Too punk rock. Too sophisticated. Too immature. He was the very embodiment of enigma but to my young mind it was that very fact that made him so alluring.
Oh! How I wanted him.
It all started innocently enough. We were both involved heavily in the music department. He had a band, mostly punk rock. He sang a cover of the Captain Planet theme song that made you admit that you did know the words to that song, and scream them at the top of your lungs, hoping he’d glance your way. He wasn’t attractive in the traditional sense. It was really more about his attitude, his aura – he was sexy. I recognized that despite the fact that I hardly knew what sexy was at that time. It didn’t matter. I’ll admit it: I was a little bit obsessed.
I can’t quite remember exactly when we became exclusive. Did we kiss first, and commit later? Did he ask me out? I’m fuzzy on the timeline. I was a Junior in High School – 17 years old, old for my grade, I fancied myself more mature. I was as foolish and as vulnerable as any other young girl in love. We were dating during the school musical, I spent rehearsals sitting in his lap in the darkened auditorium, or clinging to his side while he entertained us with his guitar. I think it was Fiddler on the Roof that year. During the first few rehearsals, we flirted. He and his best friend both courted me, flirted with me, vying for my attention and it made my head spin. I felt so powerful, and seductive, and powerful.
I chose him because it felt like electricity every time he touched me. I chose him because his breath on my ear, as he leaned in to whisper witty cynicisms I could hardly comprehend, made my spine shiver and sent my insides churning.
He wrote me poems, taping them to the inside of my locker, folded in perfect little football triangles. I don’t have them anymore. My favorite was about a caged bird who wanted to be set free to sing, a caged bird who had the power to leave her cage but didn’t because she thought she could do it tomorrow, but tomorrow would never come. He gave me that poem and a necklace, a little silver key. It was simple – cheap, even. I treasured it like nothing else I’d ever owned.
I gave him my memory books – blank notebooks that I wrote in throughout the day, jotting down anything that poppped into my head, be it doodle or words or song lyrics. It was a peek into my self. I let him have them, I let him have me, my essence.
Ultimately though, he gave me nothing. He wrote me poems about what was wrong with me in beautiful verse. He gave me symbolic gifts that urged me to change. He gave me nothing of himself. To this day I know very little about him and his life, but he knew everything about me. It was too much, I couldn’t sustain it. I couldn’t give everything and receive nothing in return. I loved him, I needed to know more of him than his favorite foods or his vocal range.
I can’t remember which of us broke it off. I remember walking down the hallway in that god-forsaken high school and passing him a note. I remember the crushing weight of my sadness on my chest making it hard to breathe. I remember him saying Goodbye. I remember the way he smelled. I remember the way he walked.
I remember riding home on the bus in a fog. I got off at my stop. I started to walk down our little dead end road. I took 10, maybe 15 steps before I broke down. I clutched the necklace he had given me, my key to happiness, and it seemed to burn my hand. I dug my fingers into my palm with this little key curled inside my angry fist and I wanted to draw blood. I stayed there, kneeling on the ground, broken, for a long while.
Finally, I rose. I took the necklace off and threw it into the woods. I went home. I did homework. I talked to a few friends. I went to sleep. I got up and I got through the next day, and the next day, and the next.
It was hard. I was heartbroken. I thought I had known love, and it was ripped away from me. I thought I might never love again.
Thankfully, I was wrong.
—————————
This post is part of Girl Talk Thursday, which is one of my favorite things ever
Want to share a story about love or heartbreak? Join in on the fun! You don’t have to post on Thursday, just post before next Thursday! And don’t forget to visit the other participants!







Those intense, blazing relationships just burn right up, don’t they? You captured it perfectly.
Kelly´s last blog ..GTT: Healed
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:32 AM
@Kelly, thanks so much! Blazing is the perfect word for it.
[Reply]
I’m with ya, sister. I know what you’re talking about – sounds all too familiar! Love can really bite sometimes. But, then again, “tomorrow *is* another day”…
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:31 AM
@Jenny, it is, and I think he was wrong. Tomorrow did come for me.
[Reply]
Love (especially at 17) is soooooo hard!!!
You made me go back to the feelings and scents and atmospheres from high school…. It’s that well written!
Severine´s last blog ..Exiled
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:31 AM
@Severine, thank you! I take that as a huge compliment – you’re too kind. I’m so glad you commented, I love adding new blogs to my reader
[Reply]
Hi! First-time commenter…found you by way of Any Mommy OUt There.
This was a lot of fun to read. I remember my first love! Ahhhhhh, memories. So glad those days of heartbreak are over! Beautifully written.
Oh, and I’m a total geek, too. WOOOHOO!!!!!
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:30 AM
@Babe in Babeland, welcome! Thanks for taking the time to comment, I always love to see a new face. GEEKS UNITE!
[Reply]
Those hot tears of teenage heartbreak. Throwing away the necklaces. Burning the love notes. You definitely brought me back with this one. Ah, to know then what we know now.
Diane´s last blog ..I did it! I won the battleship!*
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:30 AM
@Diane, if only, right? I wouldn’t have wasted a moment on him if I’d realized he’d grow up to be a pot-smoking, lonely-drinking production assistant on HGTV….
[Reply]
WOW! What fantastic writing! I was so drawn in and felt so connected to your passion/disappointment/soaring emotions. I can barely remember half of my first real relationship in high school. So .. I’m DOUBLY impressed!
Thanks for sharing.
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:29 AM
@The Ranting Mommy, thank you so much! That was my first *real* heartbreak.. so those feelings still get stirred up when I try to remember.
[Reply]
It took me nearly 30 years to realize that “This, too, shall pass.” Thank goodness. If only we had known then.
Adelas´s last blog ..GTT – Heartbreak
[Reply]
MommyGeek Reply:
December 4th, 2009 at 10:28 AM
@Adelas, I’m much better now, but yes – I wish I’d known then. And then again later that year. And then again in college. *sigh*
[Reply]
There is nothing quite like young love. Even with the emotions running so high in those times, I find that I take things harder now than I did then. I think that might be that, as an adult, I don’t necessarily pick people that are quite so ridiculous. The possibility is always there, and it is when THAT disolves that I find myself so sad and mired in pain.
[Reply]
Ahhh…this totally brought me back to those years of teenage love and angst. Honestly, I bawled my eyes out over boys far too many times. But you know what? I’d do it again. Those heartaches (if we do indeed get through them) add layers to our character that make us more interesting and empathic, don’t you think?
Boy Crazy (@claritychaos)´s last blog ..weekend update
[Reply]
You captured the feelings of having a first love. I remember thinking that I would never love anyone like I loved Greg (my first “love”). I find it comical that I thought I loved him. We dated for like a month. And he treated me like shit. He didn’t even write me poems.
christy´s last blog ..Special
[Reply]
Oh – first heartbreak is the worst. Because you really don’t know what it’s like to make it through to the other side. And since you are most likely a teenager, your angst volume goes to eleven. It’s hard being a teen – I wouldn’t go back. Okay – maybe for the first real kiss, but then straight back to my late thirties and older and wiser perspective.
Kate Coveny Hood´s last blog ..Crystal or Agate….Decisions, Decisions…
[Reply]
I love your writing. I could feel this, as I read it. xoxo
Kari´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday
[Reply]
Teenage Heartbreak – Mommies With Good Advice =( ?
[Reply]